words and their meanings

Nov 8, 2026

Language is an immensely powerful and complex psychotechnology; it is also terrifyingly confusing. Take, for example, the common phrase used by pet owners when their domesticated animal behaves quietly and properly: "good dog". But of course, they don't literally mean "good dog." For if they did, their pet would not be quiet and proper, but would instead be sprinting outside of the house, finding the nearest squirrel, and ripping it apart with gnashing teeth, spilling blood all over the freshly tailored lawn. It would then proceed to form a coalition with the other dogs in the neighborhood, with the purpose of hunting down the remaining squirrels and keeping one another warm in the night. That is a great dog. No, instead what they really mean is "thank you, dog, for behaving nothing like a dog, and instead devolving into my mute companion that I use like a tool for my entertainment and emotional regulation, all of which I deceive myself into believing is loving towards you!" But that is unspoken, and likely unknown. As are many deeper meanings within language.

Imagine a person that is repeatedly saying, "why are we here?" This truly means nothing to you without more context. So, you try to discern:

  • "Why are we here?": It appears to be an old man staring at a beautiful sunset.
    Okay, maybe he's in awe of the elusive beauty of the universe and humanity's place in it? Or perhaps he's having an existential crisis?
  • "Why are we here?": No, from the looks of it, you can piece together that he's blind and his granddaughter innocently took him to see her favorite view.
    Then, he's probably just bitter about his ailment and disappointed by the trip?
  • "Why are we here?": No, he sounds very confused and is clearly struggling to communicate with his granddaughter.
    So, he has dementia?

You're still not certain, so you decide to walk over and ask him "why do you keep saying 'why are we here?'" He turns to you; a big cheesy grin breaks out on his face as he opens his arms wide. He suddenly yells "why are we here!" and pulls you in for an awkward hug. He releases you and shakes your hand firmly before being led away by his granddaughter, who turns and looks at you over her shoulder, giggling as she says, "isn't he silly?" Congratulations, you are now more confused than when you started. Gaining more context doesn't always reveal the meaning of words.

Now, you could argue that you just don't have enough context. That's fair, so I'll give you the full story, since I am an omniscient narrator. An old, blind man is on a trip to visit his grandchildren for the first time in another country across the world. He never had a good relationship with his own children, and he's concerned his time might be coming to an end. Given this, he decided that now might be his last chance to reconcile his family relations and finally meet his grandchildren. This old man also happens to have an extremely lighthearted attitude, preferring to pass time with jokes and games as a way of protecting himself from the horrors of the world. Given this, it's no surprise that prior to his visit, he took no time to learn any single word of the language belonging to the country where his relatives reside, and upon realizing this, decided to make a game out of it. The old man thought, "I am a very perceptive man. Even more than the average man, given that I cannot use my eyes. I am certain that I can figure out this language on my own. Though, I am limited on time, so I cannot expect to learn all of this language on my short journey. I must set a reasonable, yet challenging, goal to achieve. I'll bet that I can determine the meaning of 100 phrases by the end of this trip!" And onward towards this goal the old, blind man went. As a result, he became obsessed with his game, forgetting about his deeper concerns of his age and family. He spent time with his children and grandchildren, but remained distant as he was frequently distracted by the television or strangers as they spoke words he could not understand. To his credit, on the final day of his visit he had learned 99 phrases! He had a few hours left before he had to depart, and his granddaughter led him down a pier to show him her favorite view. He had only said yes to this ridiculous request because he thought he might be able to overhear the conversations of strangers. About halfway down the pier, the old, blind man and his granddaughter walked past a group of three people fishing, and the man overheard one say loudly, "why are we here", to the other two. The old man was ecstatic! His final phrase, his final challenge. From that moment on, he kept repeating the words "why are we here" to himself, trying to somehow pick apart its meaning. He thought to himself, "This phrase must be some sort of a greeting, as that person said it exactly as we walked past them." Then, something incredible happened. After he and his granddaughter had been standing at the edge of the pier for a while, a stranger walked up to them and said "why do you keep saying 'why are we here?'". The old man was distracted muttering to himself, so the only words of this that he heard were those of the phrase he had been concerning himself with. And so, at this moment, he decided that he was correct, and thought, "How could this phrase not be a greeting?" He had done it, 100 phrases! Full of joy, he turned around to face the stranger and responded with the same greeting, saying, "why are we here!" Then he couldn't contain himself and launched forward, giving the stranger a hug to share in the excitement, and then a handshake to thank them. His journey was over, and his mission accomplished. Of course, it wasn't, not only because over half of the phrases he had learned incorrectly, but also because he reconciled not a single relationship within his family. Except, perhaps that of his granddaughter, who now thought him to be "silly."

Let's go back and say I hadn't told you the full story. Even if we were to sit down with this old man and learn about every moment across his entire life, then interview his family and friends to gain a more holistic perspective, and finally reenact a simulation of his life with trained actors, we could not gain this omniscient level of understanding for the meaning behind his words in this moment. Because in this story, everyone is wrong, except the narrator. But in our reality, there isn't a narrator. How, then, can we know what another person truly means by their words? How can we know whether they refer to the general/abstract meaning or the precise/nuanced meaning? What if they are self-deceived, misled, or speaking in metaphor? Context can help, but again it cannot bring certainty. Of course, at face value it would seem that in simple, everyday scenarios, this is not a concern. Your spouse may tell you in the morning "I am going on a run." This has some ambiguity that we could debate about, and so your spouse might instead say, "I will now temporarily relocate myself outside of the house in which we currently reside and will propel myself forward using the strength in my legs for a sum of three miles, all for the purpose of improving my cardiovascular health." This is obviously less ambiguous, and you could argue that you could not possibly misunderstand what your spouse means anymore. However, I would urge you to pick any word in their sentence and ask: what do they mean exactly when they use that word? And in answering that question, there would be even more words that require clarification, and so the cycle of question and answer would be endless.

To be clear, I am indeed claiming that there is limitless meaning to be found even in the simplest of words (perhaps similarly to the way one can "see a world in a grain of sand" per Blake's Auguries of Innocence), and therefore I am also claiming that there is a distinction between the intended meaning of a statement and the actual meaning of a statement. Given this, I am not convinced we can ever truly know with certainty what another person actually means by their words. It seems the best that we can do is be honest and empathetic in our attempts to understand one another, and hope that we receive the same in return.